Goodell Is Bad

NFL Commissioner Roger Goodellby Tuesday Moring Tailback

NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell is thinking about getting rid of kickoffs. Really? The very symbolism of starting something big may go away in the near future because of “safety concerns”. The hair-brained replacement scheme would involving the team who would normally kick off getting the ball on their own 35-yard-line, 4th down and 15, with the logic being that most teams would simply punt, which is “safer” (and far more boring) than a kickoff. Now, let’s put aside the Orwellian logic that there can be a 4th down without having a 1st, 2nd, and 3rd down. The real question is this – why is Goodell trying so desperately to destroy the game of football?

It occurred to me that most of what the Tuesday Morning Tailback has been bitching about is a direct result of policies put forth by Goodell. His inept overtime rules were addressed in our article Say Bye Bye to Sudden Death, a decision launched totally over his dissatifaction that Minnesota couldn’t stop New Orleans on the first possession of sudden death overtime in the 2009 NFC Championship Game. Goodell has also made horrible decisions, ranging from the ridiculous blinging up the players in pink
for breast cancer awareness to the hard-line stance on the Saints bounty scandal, the latest mess brought on by Goodell.

Today, former NFL commissioner Paul Tagliabue vacated all player discipline in the Saints scandal, including all suspensions and fines levied by Goodell. This comes nearly 80% through a season where a Super Bowl contender has been brought down to mediocrity, while their coach is serving a year long suspension. Goodell has constantly had his objectivity questioned on this issue (including by this column) and is currently being sued for defamation by Saints linebacker Jonathan Vilma.

Goodell’s story was compelling when he became the ninth NFL commissioner in 2006. An unlikely story of perseverance, which started when he decided at a very early age that he wanted this job of commissioner which, at that time, had been held by visionary Pete Rozell for nearly three decades.

Unfortunately, Goodell has stepped far beyond his mandate, especially when it comes to the violent nature of the game. As we first discussed in the article The NFL – It’s a Big Hit!, Goodell operates on the belief that, as the most popular sport in America, the NFL has decided it has “a responsibility” to be the best – politically.

But at the same time he is preening as a champion for safety, Goodell is pushing for two extra (18 total) regular season games. He has also rather cynically established Thursday night football all season on the league-owned NFL Network with the hope of soon selling the rights to another network. This means that teams routinely have to play games with only three days rest, vastly increasing potential injuries.

Yes, there is hypocrisy here also.


Tuesday Morning Tailback LogoTuesday Morning Tailback is a weekly article during football season which take a critical look at the NFL. We do this from the base belief that NFL football is the greatest game in the history of mankind, but some recent policies and the overall direction of the league has chipped away at this greatness. Our primary goal is to spark debate on these subjects, so please leave your own opinion on this article in the comment box below.

Leave a Reply